Переклад - la rete di monitoraggio sull’inquinamento dell’anidride solforosa.... (Італійська)

I saw a few phrases which could create a confusion in meaning in English. Busy now, but will take a closer look later!

Hi Kabetto,

The English of the text you have submitted is not very easily understandable.

In order to evaluate the translation into Italian, I first need to understand what you are trying to say in English.

Should the first line read "the city's gas..."

The second line "the new tecnology of monitoring... ...fired power plant", I don't understand what you are trying to say. What is more in English Technology needs an "h".

The rest of the English text has the same type of problems.

I think Riccio's translation is probably correct but I bet she struggled to understand the English.

Bises
Tantine

oops i thought this was into English

the Italian comes across more clearly than the original and the meaning may be slightly changed because of this: "the system of cleaning development" (which is pretty ambiguous) is translated as "lo sviluppo del sistema di depurazione" which I would translate back to "the development of the purification system" (much clearer).

lo definirei proprio biossido di zolfo;
...la nuova tecnologia di generazione di forza monitoraggio della sorgente di emissione del biossido di zolfo in centrali carbonifere;

il sistema della società adempiente gli obblighi di protezione ambientale;
istituire il sistema di informazioni per pioggia acida e base di dati per l'inquinamento di biossido di zolfo e gestione dinamica;
sistema di velocità dello scarico inquinante;

ci sono diverse imperfezioni, non solo nella traduzione, ma anche di grammatica italiana, dando origine a frasi senza senso

-gas ambientale della citta
-power generation == generazione di energia
-stabilire il sistema informatico per il database del inquinamento ...
-aliquota(?)del'inquinamento di scarico

Well, maybe the words used are okay, but I think the meaning of most of the sentences is absolutely wrong. Example:
"Sistema di scarico del tasso d'inquinamento" means "Discharge system of pollution rate", but never "Rate system of pollution discharge".
The meaning of the whole translation is wrong.

I agree with Marian: even though the source material comes across unclearly, even ambiguous sometimes, the Italian strays too far from the original English to be considered an accurate translation and there are a few errors which REALLY change the meaning. Here's another example (aside from ones already listed):
"the new tecnology of monitoring power generation" is translated as "il nuovo potere tecnologico di monitoraggio della fonte di produzione" First of all, as gigi noted, the translation of "power generation" is not correct. Also, "power" is changed to a noun and "technology" is changed to an adjective modifying "power." (potere tecnologico). Power does not belong here, as it is meant to modify "generation." In other words, "power" shouldn't be monitoring anything. The "new technology" is what's doing the monitoring...

Non mi convince soprattutto il "sistema di scarico del tasso di inquinamento", dove i termini mi sembrano scambiati rispetto all'inglese con conseguente cambiamento di senso; lo stesso discorso vale per l'ultima frase. Anche "accertare..." mi sembra leggermente diverso: non si tratta piuttosto di costituire il sistema informatico per il database ecc.?

I agree with quite all of you!

But in particular, I would say that THE SOURCE TEXT IS AWFUL!

Thanks to all.

Anyway, for example, I would say something like:


rate system of pollution discharge
sistema di valutazione dello scarico di inquinamento (???)

the system of cleaning development
Il sistema di sviluppo della depurazione (???)


rather than adopting Riccio's solutions.

Kabetto, puoi dirci qualcosa di più su questo testo?
Ad ogni modo, l'impressione che mi dà è che sia un testo italiano tradotto in inglese attraverso traduttori automatici.

is marianvr performing some chemical experimenta?

CC: kabetto Ricciodimare

Hi Folks

This text seems to have created too many problems for the English to Italian translators. This is the sixth attempt to produce a coherent text in Italian.

I have posted a message under the original asking the submitter to clean up his text and submit a coherent text in English.

If it is possible I will make sure that the rejected texts be rejected with a decent rating since it is not the fault of the translators. The source text is not translatable in its present form.

I hope this is ok with everyone.

Bises
Tantine

CC: kabetto Ricciodimare kafetzou Xini

Well, I checked and I gave all "no rating". Same for Riccio's only rejection. I just gave 0 for a clear machine traslation.

Tantine, why did you cc me on this?

credo che "rate system of pollution discharge" sia meglio traducubile con "sistema di valutazione delle emissioni inquinanti"

Hi Kafetzou,

I'm sorry, I can't remember

Maybe it was so you could see what awful English the original was?

OK; I'm going to unsubscribe to notifications now. But thanks anyhow!

Não há "power plant" no segundo parágrafo traduzido para o italiano.

Nu e o traducere prea exacta, si consider ca ar fi fost necesara una intr-un text stiintific.

Kabetto, ma dove diavolo l'hai trovato questo benedetto testo?¿?

CC: kabetto