| | |
| | 1 Septembrie 2008 15:44 |
| Oana F.Numărul mesajelor scrise: 388 | Lilian, the verb "start" doesn't request the infinitive? "start to do something", then, is not "you hadn't started", but "I hadn't started". Not "early in the evening", but yesterday evening. Anyway thank you very much for the tenses. |
| | 1 Septembrie 2008 15:45 |
| Oana F.Numărul mesajelor scrise: 388 | and which is better, "cook" or "bake"? |
| | 1 Septembrie 2008 15:49 |
| guilonNumărul mesajelor scrise: 1549 | La sera prima = yesterday evening
Also, I think ->se non avessi cominciato = if I hadn't started, hard to say because of the lack of context but more logical at first sight. |
| | 1 Septembrie 2008 15:56 |
| | "Start" is usually followed by a gerund. About "cuocere", it may be "cook", "bake" or even "steam", it depends on what comes after it.
cuocere al forno, cuocere al vapore, cuocere allo spiedo, etc
Since the kind wasn't specified I chose "cook" which has a general meaning. I agree that a turkey is usually "baked" though.
Anyway it seems that my understanding is not correct seeing that Guilon voted against the translation. Let's see what else is wrong.
Guilon? CC: guilon |
| | 1 Septembrie 2008 16:01 |
| | Oh you were faster!
I know that "la sera prima" means "the evening before", but it doesn't make sense in this case, don't you think?
That's why I thought that "prima" should be "early" |
| | 1 Septembrie 2008 16:09 |
| guilonNumărul mesajelor scrise: 1549 | You are right, the whole text is a bit misleading, but on the other hand, there is no way an Italian speaker could understand "la sera prima" as "early in the evening".
As for "se non avessi cominciato a cuocere", if it was a "you" action, I think an Italian would naturally say "se tu non avessi cominciato a cuocere" in order to make a clear difference of subjects in the two sentences. |
| | 1 Septembrie 2008 16:10 |
| Oana F.Numărul mesajelor scrise: 388 | I don't agree about the verb "start". A gerund is requested after "stop", for example. "start" has a view in the future. "Stop" breaks an action and that's why it requests a gerund. I think you are right, "an evening before" is not the best translation, maybe "yesterday evening", or maybe your translation is ok. Anyway you helped me a lot with the tenses, thank you |
| | 1 Septembrie 2008 16:13 |
| Oana F.Numărul mesajelor scrise: 388 | Thank you, Lilian. Thank you, Guilon |
| | 1 Septembrie 2008 16:16 |
| guilonNumărul mesajelor scrise: 1549 | Oana, lilian speaks English so well that she is an expert for that language in cucumis.
From Oxford dictionary:
start |stärt|
• [with infinitive or present participle ] embark on a continuing action or a new venture : I started to chat to him | we plan to start building in the fall.
|
| | 1 Septembrie 2008 16:27 |
| Oana F.Numărul mesajelor scrise: 388 | Guilon, I think there is no need for you to be ironic, I know very well Lilian is an expert, though I can say my opinion, or not? If someone doesn't agree with me, he/she can explain why, without having the attitude you had. I just know that the professors made a clear distinction about the situations when to use "infinitive" and when "gerund" regarding the verb "start". I am not English native speaker, so I am interested to discuss with native speakers, to be contradicted, but I do not like ironical answers. |
| | 1 Septembrie 2008 16:50 |
| | Oana,
Many verbs in English may be followed either by an infinitive or by a gerund. The use of the gerund after verbs like: stop, finish, begin, start, is a lot more common than the infinitive. That's because as we say, they are kind of "prepositional" verbs, that means it's like if a preposition is included in the verb. And as you know after a preposition, a gerund is used.
And...I don't think Guilon was "ironic", he just tried to show you that you had a wrong idea about something. That's something to thank for, we are learning each day. |
| | 1 Septembrie 2008 17:02 |
| Oana F.Numărul mesajelor scrise: 388 | Thank you, Lilian, for your explanations, this what I like and what I am thankful for. You know I rejected the translations of this text 2 times without any comment. I started to comment when you translated it, because I know a native speaker can give good explanations, and this is what you did. I cannot be thankful for something else, especially when that something comes from an administrator. I hate this discussion |
| | 1 Septembrie 2008 20:10 |
| | I think that the right translation of "la sera prima" is "yesterday evening". "Early in the evening"can be traslate " la sera sul presto". |
| | 2 Septembrie 2008 16:22 |
| | |
| | 2 Septembrie 2008 16:36 |
| Oana F.Numărul mesajelor scrise: 388 | wild turkey??? you are kidding, aren't you? |