Cucumis - Free online translation service
. .



Original text - Latin - Astrahentium non est mendacium

Current statusOriginal text
This text is available in the following languages: LatinBrazilian Portuguese

Title
Astrahentium non est mendacium
Text to be translated
Submitted by alinevilar
Source language: Latin

Astrahentium non est mendacium
13 March 2009 01:02





Latest messages

Author
Message

8 June 2009 12:00

lilian canale
Number of messages: 14972
Hi chronotribe, could you please give a bridge for evaluation, here?

CC: chronotribe

8 June 2009 12:51

chronotribe
Number of messages: 119
This is a scholastic maxim, that can be translated : "abstraction does not falsify" (lit.: there is no lie of/from those who abstract) and is traditionally referred to Aristote (II Physic., 193b 35).

Scotus (in II Physic., Expositio 20 textus 1 says: "Et si
aliquis dicat, quod Mathematici tunc faciunt mendacium: quia considerant ista,
quasi essent abstracta a motu, et materia; quae tamen sunt coniuncta materiae.
Respondet, quod non faciunt mendacium: quia Mathematicus non considerat,
utrum id, de quo demonstrat suas passiones, sit coniunctum materiae, vel
abstractum a materia."
[And if someone says that mathematicians tell lies because they consider these things as if they were abstracted from move and matter, whereas they are conjoined with matter; he responds that they do not tell lies, because mathematician doesn't consider whether it, about which he demonstrates its passions (= accidents), is conjoined with matter or abstracted from matter.]