Cucumis - Free online translation service
. .



Translation - Georgian-English - rogor xar?

Current statusTranslation
This text is available in the following languages: GeorgianEnglishPolish

This translation request is "Meaning only".
Title
rogor xar?
Text
Submitted by pantelena
Source language: Georgian

rogor xar?

Title
How are you?
Translation
English

Translated by pirulito
Target language: English

How are you?
Remarks about the translation
როგორ ხარ?
Validated by Una Smith - 3 October 2008 18:26





ตอบล่าสุด

ผู้ตั้ง
ตอบ

3 October 2008 19:35

lilian canale
จำนวนข้อความ: 14972
Do you know Georgian, Una?

Why did you validate this translation which was in a poll for its meaning to be checked?


CC: Una Smith

3 October 2008 20:18

lilian canale
จำนวนข้อความ: 14972
I guess you didn't notice the warning
"This evaluation is managed by Lilian Canale"

CC: Una Smith cucumis

3 October 2008 22:44

Una Smith
จำนวนข้อความ: 429
I looked it up. I reduced the English backlog by one whole translation, without a long wait and without many, many Cucumis users spending their valuable time on it.

3 October 2008 22:55

Una Smith
จำนวนข้อความ: 429
Why doesn't this page show the submission date?

3 October 2008 23:56

Francky5591
จำนวนข้อความ: 12396
Submission date is under the original text.
According to the link I provided under the Georgian text that tells about its meaning, it is validable.

Don't worry too much, as requester as well could have a look and probably used this translation already, maybe did s/he check veracity from the link too, all I can say about this translation is that, even if I saw on the internet that "rogor xar?" meant "how are you?", I still can't assume it is the right meaning.

Serious sources are dictionaries and/or some bilinguist speaking source and target-language who could have helped us.

pirulito and I even were unable to assume how it really reads in Georgian, as we haven't got more references than that in Georgian...

So who's right, who's wrong about priority in validating a text without being 100% sure, and importance of the English backlog? Probably both.
One thing is sure, it is that you and Lilian should work hand in hand to solve the problem.

I don't blame any of you two, how could I? You both are nice members and everyone of you contributes to the improvement of our dear site cucumis.

So please make peace for the safe of this wonderful site, and I'm sure we'll succeed to overcome all the difficulties.


4 October 2008 01:24

Una Smith
จำนวนข้อความ: 429
Francky, I used dictionaries and other technical sources. I confirmed the script correspondence (pirulito got that right too) and I parsed each word. Furthermore, one of my technical sources included a direct translation of the phrase "how are you".

I am 100% sure and pirulito did good work there.



CC: pirulito Francky5591

4 October 2008 01:27

Una Smith
จำนวนข้อความ: 429
Oops, checking the discussion under the original, it was good teamwork with Francky.

CC: pirulito Francky5591

6 October 2008 11:45

cucumis
จำนวนข้อความ: 3785
OK fine. Thank you Francly, this is exaclty what I think.
Una, we introduced a new tool a couple of weeks ago to avoid that experts of the same language work on the same translation. There is a button "I manage this trans".

When there is a text "This evaluation is managed by XXX", that means the expert will come back to evaluate the translation. I think it's better to respect this. If you think you can evaluate without waiting, you can do it but just post a message to inform the expert once you've evaluated.