Cucumis - Free online translation service
. .



Translation - Malay-English - de sekeras itu kah hati k3 mu .dia ga ...

Current statusTranslation
This text is available in the following languages: MalayEnglishArabic

กลุ่ม Chat

This translation request is "Meaning only".
Title
de sekeras itu kah hati k3 mu .dia ga ...
Text
Submitted by s,lm
Source language: Malay

de sekeras itu kah hati k3 mu .dia ga mau dgr aq dn dia ga mau menjlaskn pdlk . skrngpun dia dah ga mau bcr pdlku
Remarks about the translation
مسج مرسل من مبايل خادمتي

Title
Obstinate
Translation
English

Translated by gbernsdorff
Target language: English

Your brother is so obstinate. He doesn't want to listen to me and he doesn't want to explain to me. Now he doesn't even want to talk to me.
Validated by lilian canale - 16 November 2009 11:52





ตอบล่าสุด

ผู้ตั้ง
ตอบ

2 September 2009 02:02

lilian canale
จำนวนข้อความ: 14972
Hi gbernsdorff,

...he doesn't want to explain (what?)

2 September 2009 23:24

gbernsdorff
จำนวนข้อความ: 240
That is not clear. Menjelaskan is the verb. *pdlk* must be the direct object, if any. I have encountered that once as an abbreviation for *perjalanan dinas luar kota* [out of town duty trip], but I can't be sure.

2 September 2009 23:51

lilian canale
จำนวนข้อความ: 14972
Perhaps "explain himself'?

3 September 2009 23:51

gbernsdorff
จำนวนข้อความ: 240
You are suggesting *to explain* in the sense of *to account for something/to justify oneself*. That is one possible interpretation, but the text doesn't say so, for that would be *menjelaskan diri sendiri*. I don't see how that could be abbreviated to pdlk.

3 September 2009 23:54

lilian canale
จำนวนข้อความ: 14972
In your opinion, in what sense is 'explain' used here?

4 September 2009 21:47

gbernsdorff
จำนวนข้อความ: 240
One of two possibilities. Either, as you suggested, explain oneself/justify oneself, or answer a specific question which has been asked before and therefore is known to the addressee. Yet another possibility would be that *pdlk* is a typo for *pdk* [l and k are next to each other on the keyboard!], in which case it would mean menjelaskan padaku/explain to me. *pdk* is quite frequent as an abbreviation in Malay textese. - Yes indeed, that may be the best option. I see that I even interpreted the last word (pdlku) as *padaku/to me*. Should have thought of that before! I have changed the translation accordingly.

4 September 2009 23:11

lilian canale
จำนวนข้อความ: 14972
OK, but that doesn't solve the problem of the missing direct object yet.
We still don't know 'what' is not explained.

4 September 2009 23:57

gbernsdorff
จำนวนข้อความ: 240
Do we need to know ? If we take it that pdlk means "to me" there really is no other indication in the Malay text as to what he doesn't want to explain. Is that a problem ? Both Malay 'menjelaskan' and English 'to explain' can be used as intransitive verbs i.e. without a direct object. É parecido em português não é? Podemos dizer 'Prefiro não explicar.' sem acrescentar o que já se sabe. Ou será que me engano?
Regards, Guido

5 September 2009 00:16

lilian canale
จำนวนข้อความ: 14972
'explain' as intransitive verb implies 'explain oneself', otherwise, it is transitive.
You could use it that way, but then it should read:
"He doesn't want to listen to me or explain himself"

What do you think?

5 September 2009 00:19

s,lm
จำนวนข้อความ: 1
Thank you all
But I am really quite ignorant of the Malay language


5 September 2009 10:38

gbernsdorff
จำนวนข้อความ: 240
Once we have decided that pdlk must be padaku i.e. an indirect object, there is no other word or abbreviation that could function as a direct object. Intransitiviy can be made explicit by saying menjelaskan diri sendiri/explain himself. Transitivity can be made explicit by attaching
-nya (menjelaskannya/explain it). The Malay text does neither, it gives us no clue as to the (in)transitivity of the verb. The English translation should leave that question open too, hence: we leave it as it is, we do not add either the reflexive pronoun nor a direct object.