Cucumis - Free online translation service
. .



Translation - Esperanto-English - Por studi la ceremoniojn ni komencis studi unue...

Current statusTranslation
This text is available in the following languages: EsperantoEnglish

Title
Por studi la ceremoniojn ni komencis studi unue...
Text
Submitted by alireza
Source language: Esperanto

Por studi la ceremoniojn ni komencis studi unue la antikva penso de Irananoj kaj ilia geografia kaj natura stato, ĝis eble oni povus uzi ilin.

Title
In order to study the ceremonies
Translation
English

Translated by goncin
Target language: English

In order to study the ceremonies, first we began studying Iranians' ancient thinking and their geography and natural state, to the point where one could use the studies.
Last validated or edited by kafetzou - 5 April 2008 07:07





Latest messages

Author
Message

19 March 2008 16:56

kafetzou
Number of messages: 7963
at first --> first

19 March 2008 17:10

goncin
Number of messages: 3706

19 March 2008 17:23

kafetzou
Number of messages: 7963
Good. What does "them" refer to - the ceremonies or the Iranians? I don't understand that part.

19 March 2008 17:32

goncin
Number of messages: 3706
Neither - "them" is intended to refer to "Iranians' ancient thinking and their geography and natural state". Would "to the point one may use these" solve that ambiguity (which comes from the source text)?

23 March 2008 18:57

kafetzou
Number of messages: 7963
Sorry - it still doesn't make sense in English - what is "to the point"? Do you mean "until" or "so that"?

Also, it should be "began", not "have begun".

23 March 2008 22:48

goncin
Number of messages: 3706
Is it correct now?

24 March 2008 01:23

kafetzou
Number of messages: 7963
I'm not sure. I don't understand what "until one may use them" means - does it mean that that is when we will stop studying them? Can you translate "ĝis eble oni povus uzi ilin" word for word (including cases and persons) for me?

24 March 2008 10:58

goncin
Number of messages: 3706
Well... here it goes:

ĝis = until
eble = maybe
oni = one (undefinite subject)
povus = to be able to (conditional mood)
uzi = to use (infinitive)
ilin = them (3rd person plural, accusative case)

(I don't think it helps that much, though... )

24 March 2008 17:10

kafetzou
Number of messages: 7963
Wow - thanks, goncin, but as you say, it doesn't really solve the problem.

Do you think it means something like "to the point where the studies were usable (by other people)"?

24 March 2008 17:11

goncin
Number of messages: 3706
Yep. It's what I wanted to mean when I first wrote "to the point one could use them"...

24 March 2008 17:18

kafetzou
Number of messages: 7963
OK - I edited with that and have put a note below. I'll put this one to a vote.

24 March 2008 17:20

kafetzou
Number of messages: 7963
Sorry - on re-read, this just doesn't work, because the word "studies" doesn't appear in the English, so the English reader assumes that some other plural noun is the referent. I will re-edit.

24 March 2008 17:40

goncin
Number of messages: 3706
I'm trying to help alireza with these texts in Esperanto, but the texts in Esperanto simply don't help me... stevo (another Esperanto expert) has done one of these texts, not more successful than me...