Tafsiri - Kipolishi-Kiukreni - transport koszt odbiorcy

ukrainian: переклад зроблено неправильно.
polish: błędne tłumaczenie.
english: translation is done wrong.

afkalin, can you check this ?

CC: afkalin

correctly:
english: shipping is paid by a recipient
russian: доставка за счёт получателя
ukrainian: доставку оплачує отримувач

What's going on here?

1) The translation seems to have nothing to do with the source text, and

2) Both were submitted by the same person. Could someone who speaks Russian and/or Ukrainian please write to him and ask him what's going on with this?

CC: afkalin Melissenta ramarren

I do not know polish, but, according to the meaning, I would rather agree with slbgz. As to submitter, I do not think that there's any sense to talk to him(her), because if she had known the meaning (translation) she would not have asked Cucumis community...

But it seems that afkalin has accepted this translation ...

I think that afkalin did not have a right to accept translation from Polish as he is not an expert from Polish.

an original text is typical formulation, which is used for description of manners of payment and delivery in the internet sales:
http://www.google.com.ua/search?q=transport+koszt+odbiorcy&hl=uk&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:uk-UA:official&hs=GTp&start=10&sa=N

other variant more correct original text:
«transport towarów odbywa się na koszt odbiorcy»
«transport opłaca odbiorcа»
«transport na koszt odbiorcy»
«koszt dostawy uiszcza odbiorca»

jp, can you help here? It seems that afkalin has validated a translation that is not valid, and in a language in which he is not an expert.



CC: cucumis

I've edited the translation with your suggestion, slbgz.

Acutally, afkalin is an expert for the target language, so he has the right to evaluate it. Maybe he did it to quick without using the poll used when we don't know the source language .

CC: afkalin

Oops - I wrote my note too quickly - of course he's an expert for Ukrainian.

Thanks,
I accede to you, but, in my opinion, member, which does not own an initial language, not must accept translations from this language…

Ооps, jp,
translation on Ukrainian is:
«доставку оплачує отримувач»,
or:
«доставка за рахунок отримувача».
not:
«переклад зроблено неправильно»=«translation is done wrong»

Спасибо за исправление - приношу свои извинения за поспешно принятый ошибочный перевод.

afkalin, could you please edit this to a correct translation. I could not understand your note above.

CC: afkalin

slbgz, we have a system of polls. When the expert doesn't understand the source language, all members who understand the both languages can vote. The experts know if the translation is correctly formed, and the members know if the meaning is correct. After there are enough votes, the expert can make a decision.

I see that afkalin has edited the translation now, thanks

Ok, thanks jp, kafetzou, afkalin